Last-Click vs Data-Driven Attribution Models: What is Right for Your Brand?

Reading Time: 6 minutes

In the world of marketing, attribution models identify and assign credit to the various interactions (interactions) that contribute to a consumer’s decision to convert (purchase or take a desired action). This helps marketers understand which channels, campaigns, or interactions are most effective in driving conversions. Understanding attribution is crucial because choosing the right model can be complex. These insights are invaluable for optimizing your marketing efforts, revealing new opportunities, and identifying areas for improvement. 

Why Attribution Models Matter ?

• Budget Allocation: Helps in allocating marketing budgets more effectively by identifying high-performing channels.
• Performance Optimization: Provides insights into the effectiveness of different marketing strategies.
• Customer Insights: Offers a deeper understanding of customer behavior and preferences.
• ROI Measurement: Assists in measuring the return on investment for various marketing activities.

Additional Read: Top marketing attribution models tools and softwares (easyinsights.ai)

We’ve established that attribution is crucial for understanding which marketing channels truly drive conversions. Now, let’s delve into the two attribution models available on Google: Last-Click Attribution and Data-Driven.

Last-Click Attribution Models : 

Last-click attribution as the name suggests assigns credit for a conversion to the last interaction by a customer before making a purchase. In this model, the entirety of the credit for a conversion is given to the last interaction that the customer engaged with before making a purchase or completing a desired action. This means that regardless of how many interactions occurred along the customer journey, the final interaction before conversion is considered the most significant and receives 100% of the credit. Most platforms, including Google Analytics, use this as their default attribution approach.

Pros of Last-Click Attribution

The last Click Attribution Model provides several benefits for marketers by focusing on the last touchpoint before the conversion. Here are some key benefits

• Simplicity: The Last-Click model is straightforward to grasp and implement since it doesn’t necessitate extensive data analysis or advanced tracking methods.
• Conversion-Focused: Useful for understanding which interactions directly lead to sales or desired actions.
• Broad Industry Support: Numerous analytics and advertising platforms, like Google Analytics and Facebook Ads Manager, support last-click attribution, enhancing its appeal to marketers.

Cons of Last-Click Attribution

Despite its benefits, Last-Click Attribution has inherent limitations:

• Ignores Initial and Middle Interactions: Fails to acknowledge the role of earlier touchpoints in the customer journey.
• Overvalues Final Interaction: This can lead to undervaluing important channels that drive customer engagement and nurturing.
• Incomplete Insight: This does not provide a comprehensive view of the entire customer journey, potentially missing key insights for optimization.

When to Use the Last-Click Attribution Models

The Last Click Attribution Model is particularly useful in certain scenarios. Here’s when you should consider using it:

• Limited Resources:  For marketing teams with limited resources or technical expertise, the simplicity of last-click attribution is a major perk. Data is readily available in most marketing platforms, requiring minimal setup and analysis. This makes it a user-friendly option for startups or businesses just getting started with attribution.
• Direct Response Campaigns: Campaigns focused on driving immediate actions, such as sales promotions or time-sensitive offers, the Last-Click model can provide clear insights into what drove the final action. It is particularly effective for understanding the final push that led to a conversion.

Data-Driven Attribution Models :

Data-driven attribution (DDA) uses advanced algorithms and machine learning to evaluate the impact of each touchpoint in the customer journey, assigning conversion credit based on the actual contribution of each interaction. It works by collecting data from all customer interactions across multiple channels, utilizing machine learning models to analyze patterns and determine the contribution of each touchpoint, and then proportionally distributing conversion credit based on the impact of each touchpoint.

Pros of Data-Driven Attribution Models :

Through data analysis, DDA models can identify patterns and evaluate how each interaction influences the probability of conversion. Compared to traditional last-click attribution, data-driven attribution provides numerous advantages.

• Accuracy: Provides a highly accurate representation of how different interactions contribute to conversions by using real data and advanced algorithms.
• Dynamic Adjustments: Continuously updates the attribution model based on new data, ensuring that insights remain relevant and reflective of current marketing dynamics.
• Comprehensive Analysis: Evaluates all interactions in the customer journey, offering a holistic view of the marketing efforts and their effectiveness.
• Unbiased Credit Distribution: Eliminates the inherent biases present in rule-based models by relying on data-driven insights.
• Optimization Opportunities: Identifies high-performing channels and interactions, enabling marketers to allocate resources more effectively and optimize campaigns for better ROI.
• Adaptability: Adapts to changes in consumer behavior and market conditions, ensuring that the attribution model remains relevant over time.

Cons of Data-Driven Attribution:

Despite its advantages in providing a nuanced understanding of how different marketing efforts contribute to conversions, the Data-Driven Attribution Model has several inherent limitations. Let’s delve into these limitations in more detail:

• Transparency Challenges: The intricate nature of the algorithms can obscure how attribution credit is distributed, posing potential transparency issues for marketers.
• Data Dependency: Data-driven attribution (DDA) models require a significant volume of conversion data to generate reliable and actionable insights. This prerequisite can disadvantage smaller businesses or campaigns with lower conversion rates, as they may not generate sufficient data to effectively train the model using the default data-driven methodology.

When to Use the Data-Driven Attribution Models

To make the most of the Time Decay Attribution Model, marketers should adopt best practices that enhance its advantages while addressing potential limitations:

• Complex Customer Journeys: When your customer journey includes numerous touchpoints across different channels, like digital advertisements, email promotions, social media engagements, and offline interactions. For instance, an e-commerce platform could employ DDA to analyze the impact of online browsing behaviors, customer feedback interactions, and loyalty program engagements on purchasing decisions.
• Advanced Analytics Capabilities: With access to substantial volumes of high-quality data from multiple channels, DDA excels in generating precise insights. For instance, a telecommunications company utilizing sophisticated data analytics across web interactions, mobile app usage, and customer service touchpoints can effectively leverage DDA to optimize service offerings and customer engagement strategies.

Summary

Feature	Last-Click Attribution	Data-Driven Attribution
Simplicity	High	Low
Consideration of Touchpoints	Single (Last)	Multiple (All)
Implementation	Easy	Complex
Accuracy	Low (Ignores early touchpoints)	High (Considers all interactions)
Data Requirement	Low	High
Best for	Short sales cycles, Beginners	Complex journeys, Advanced users

Additional Read: First Party Data: The Answer to Third Party Cookie Loss 

Conclusion

To choose the right attribution model, start by assessing your business needs. Consider the length of your sales cycle as short sales cycles may benefit from the simplicity of last-click attribution, while longer cycles may require the comprehensive view provided by data-driven attribution. Evaluate your data availability and analytics capabilities; last-click attribution might be a practical starting point if you have limited data or analytics capabilities. As your data capabilities grow, you can transition to data-driven attribution. 

Additionally, consider your analytics resources, as Data-driven attribution can offer significant insights but requires investment in tools and expertise. It’s advisable to evolve your approach over time. If you’re new to attribution modeling, start simple with last-click attribution to gain basic insights. As you become more comfortable with attribution analysis and your data capabilities improve, consider moving to more advanced models like data-driven attribution.

Amidst this need for a more comprehensive attribution model and the evolving digital landscape, future-proofing your marketing strategy is essential, especially with the phasing out of third-party cookies. EasyInsights offers a reliable solution for attribution challenges by leveraging server-side tracking to gather first-party data. This enables seamless navigation of digital complexities and unlocks detailed insights, robust analytics, and a composable CDP to navigate digital complexities and unlock valuable growth insights. Book a demo to learn more.

Additional Read: When to Use Last-Click Attribution in Marketing | EasyInsights